Sacramento County Superior Court, California. Reported as No. 26WM000254 by Hogan Lovells Cadwalader (November 6, 2026); not confirmed on the court docket. Filed October 23, 2026. This page covers what is challenged, where the case stands, and who is covered by any relief granted.
This page is free to read and updated weekly, and the fee calculator needs a free EPR Atlas account.
Last updated November 22, 2026.
Sacramento County Superior Court, California | Reported as No. 26WM000254 by Hogan Lovells Cadwalader (November 6, 2026); not confirmed on the court docket | Filed October 23, 2026 current November 18, 2026
This summary of where the case stands is not legal advice. If your exposure is material, confirm it with counsel.
SB 54’s producer charges. As Foley and Lardner summarizes the verified petition, the California Restaurant Association argues that SB 54’s charges are taxes and that article XI, section 11 of the California Constitution bars the Legislature from handing the power to tax to a private party, here Circular Action Alliance California.
A verified petition for peremptory writ of mandate, alternative writ of mandate, and complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief was filed October 23, 2026 against Circular Action Alliance California and CalRecycle, among others (Hogan Lovells Cadwalader, November 6, 2026; Foley and Lardner, October 26, 2026). As Foley summarizes it, the petition seeks to require CAA to rescind its invoices, refund payments, and stop spending the money it has collected, and Foley notes that no earlier EPR challenge has raised the tax argument. No ruling, hearing date, or response has been reported. The Atlas has not read the petition, because the court’s civil case portal was offline when tried on November 18, 2026, so this record is carried at signaled.
No relief granted. SB 54 remains in force, and producers’ registration, reporting, and payment obligations continue while the case proceeds (Foley and Lardner).
The main filings, orders, and related events are listed in date order, and a date marked scheduled has not happened yet.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| October 23, 2026 | Verified petition filed by the California Restaurant Association in Sacramento County Superior Court against Circular Action Alliance California and CalRecycle, among others (as reported by Foley and Lardner and Hogan Lovells Cadwalader). |
| Pending scheduled | No ruling or hearing date reported. |
Dates are drawn from court filings, orders, and firm alerts as reported. Where a docket is not publicly accessible the Atlas relies on secondary reporting and says so.
Status as of November 18, 2026. Foley and Lardner (October 26, 2026) and Hogan Lovells Cadwalader (November 6, 2026) read November 18, 2026; the petition and docket not read. Carried at signaled.
Every state guide has the fee schedule where one has been published, registration deadlines, program plan status, eco-modulation detail, the statute and any implementing rule, and exemptions.